Categories
Uncategorized

Jagged Little Pill on Broadway - An Epic Experience

I wanted to hate it. I tried to hate it. But I fucking loved it.

It was early December of 2019 when it happened. I had just finished a vigorous level 2 vinyasa flow at my favorite NYC yoga studio. As the flow came to an end, we prepared for my favorite part of class: savasana. The 10-ish minutes of class when you lie on your back to breathe and reflect on the previous 80-ish minutes. The teacher typically plays a relaxing song to set the mood. But this teacher’s particular song choice that day threw me a curveball. She played the Broadway version of “You Learn”. This song choice made me feel the opposite of relaxed. I cried. Not tears of joy — tears of sadness and confusion and myriad other feelings that overwhelmed me. Hearing the cast of predominantly young Millennials and Gen Z kids singing reimagined versions of my favorite songs….hurt.

Like millions of other people, I’m emotionally attached to the Alanis Morissette originals that came out 25 years ago. I’ve listened to Jagged Little Pill thousands of times. That album grew with me. Life continued to happen but that album stayed the same. I knew that a Jagged Little Pill musical was coming so I did my best to avoid it by scrolling past all forms of press, interviews, and sound bites. I didn’t realize how much Jagged Little Pill (the album) meant to me until I found myself low key protesting the Broadway buzz.

Early December was also when I went to Alanis’s one-night-only show at The Apollo. This was a SoBerthday gift to myself to celebrate 4 years of continuous sobriety. She performed her iconic album (plus a few favorites) in an acoustic setting for an intimate crowd followed up a Q&A. I recently wrote about it for AudioFemme. Alanis frequently referred to the musical. She cried when talking about how much the show meant to her. How seeing a team of talented people adapt her album into a Broadway show humbled her as an artist. My bitterness toward the musical softened as I heard her endorsement. I was ready to see it. I couldn’t keep bashing a show that I hadn’t even seen.

The day after that Alanis essay was published, Big Vision, an NYC-based non-profit that creates sober experiences for NYC folks 35 and under, announced a contest to win tickets to Jagged Little Pil on Broadway. I submitted my essay…and won!

The Show

Not only was I lucky enough to see the show with an amazing group of people behind Big Vision and fellow contest winners, but I also had the privilege of sitting in the fourth row. Jagged Little Pill - The Musical tackles several heavy topics in such a short period of time: the opioid epidemic, #meToo, racism, and sexuality just to name a few. Diablo Cody (Oscar-Winning screenwriter who wrote Juno, Young Adult, and more) did such a brilliant job of highlighting these important issues while incorporating songs from a legendary album while also keeping the audience - including this hyper skeptical Alanis fanatic - completely engaged the entire time.

The ensemble was genuinely diverse, not diverse because it’s trendy. Incredibly talented humans of all races and genders and sexualities were represented while telling a beautiful, important story. The 90’s-inspired outfits had me soaking up all of the nostalgia. I would 100% see it again just to rewatch Lauren Patten perform “You Oughta Know”. For a full review of the show, check out Jesse Green’s write up for the NY Times review here.

Talk Back

Big Vision went above and beyond to make this a night to remember. Once the show ended and the theater cleared, two of the actors (Elizabeth Stanley and Sean Allan Krill) did a Talk Back with our group. They opened up about what the show meant to them and we asked them questions in return.

Someone asked the actors how they separate themselves from playing these intense roles. Krill had a brilliant response that I’ll paraphrase: When he gets home, he goes to a lightswitch, reminds himself that he loves this job but he has to clock out. Then he physically flips the light switch. As a fellow creative who struggles with knowing when to clock out, I appreciated the symbolism. His visual went a long way with me. Stanley opened up about how addiction has impacted her life, which led to her originating such a well-rounded lead role in the musical.


I really wanted to hate this show. I’ve spent so much energy on hiding from it. It’s not that I wanted it to be something that it wasn’t, I simply didn’t even want it to be. I now understand how my mom felt when Glee covered “Paradise by the Dashboard Light” by Meatloaf or when Deadheads were upset that John Mayer began touring with The Dead. I defended Glee and John Mayer because I saw that they were bringing excellent music to a younger fanbase. Now I can see that that’s what Jagged Little Pill - the Musical is doing, too.


Tawny is an NYC-based writer, public speaker, and event producer who’s passionate about smashing stigmas associated with both sexuality and sobriety. She’s been dubbed “The Sober Sexpert” by Ruby Warrington.

Tawny’s words are published in PlayboyHuffington PostThe TemperAudiofemmeSheSaidRecovery CampusWorkIt Health, and NY Yoga & Life Magazine. Tawny shared her recovery story on stages all across the world: IOGT World CongressNew York State Recovery ConferenceUnited Federation of Teachers, and more.

In addition to writing and public speaking, she’s the founder of the Readings on Recovery™ reading series and SobrieTea Party and co-host of Recovery Rocks podcast with Lisa Smith. She’s also a charity volunteer with Road Recovery and an award-winning filmmaker of the recovery documentary, Fixed Up.

By Tawny

Tawny is an NYC-based writer, public speaker, and event producer who’s passionate about smashing stigmas associated with both sexuality and sobriety. She’s recently been dubbed “The Sober Sexpert” by Ruby Warrington.

Tawny’s words have been published in Playboy, Huffington Post, The Temper, XOJane, Audiofemme, SheSaid, Recovery Campus, WorkIt Health, and NY Yoga & Life Magazine. Tawny has shared her recovery story on stages all across the world: IOGT World Congress, New York State Recovery Conference, United Federation of Teachers, and more.

In addition to writing and public speaking, she’s the founder of the Readings on Recovery™ reading series and SobrieTea Party™, co-host of Recovery Rocks podcast with Lisa Smith, charity volunteer with Road Recovery, and an award-winning filmmaker of the recovery documentary, Fixed Up. When she’s not working on all of the things, she’s doing yoga or eating tacos - sometimes simultaneously.

Leave a Reply